Listen to this article
John Shepherd · Premium Works Journal · 9 min 17 sec
There have been many times in my life when I strongly believed God was calling me to do something. One of the biggest happened within the last fourteen months, when I moved from one side of the country to the other.
This wasn’t a small decision. It required an enormous financial commitment. I stretched myself almost to the breaking point to make the move happen. There were moments along the journey when I had very little choice but to trust God with my decisions, my travels, my finances, and ultimately where my family and I were going to end up.
And during that time, I felt incredibly close to God.
I prayed. I trusted. I worshipped. I watched a journey unfold that, at times, I genuinely didn’t believe I was capable of completing. When we finally arrived and secured a house, there was an incredible sense that we had made it.
Then things started falling apart.
My marriage came under significant strain. Friendships came under strain. Financial pressure followed me into the new life I had worked so hard to reach. Eventually I found myself returning to the normal nine-to-five grind, and the connection with God that had felt so strong during the journey began to weaken.
Naturally, I started asking a difficult question:
Did God actually lead me here, or did I convince myself that He did?
Hearing Something Doesn’t Mean I Should Automatically Follow It
I believe God communicates with us. I have experienced thoughts and direction in my life that I strongly believe were not simply coming from me.
But I have also learned something uncomfortable about myself: I haven’t always been very good at testing those thoughts.
That matters.
If I believe God is directing me toward something, simply feeling strongly about it isn’t enough. I have to make that thought subject to Christ. I have to test it against Scripture. I have to pray over it and ask whether what I believe I am hearing is consistent with the character and Spirit of God.
I’ve learned to do something similar with negative thoughts.
There are times when a thought about myself enters my mind that essentially says, You’re garbage. You’ve failed. You’re worthless.
There may be something I genuinely need to correct. Christ can convict me. Scripture can expose something in my life that needs to change. But conviction leads somewhere. There is repentance, correction, forgiveness and ultimately restoration.
The endless circular thought that simply tells me how terrible I am without leading anywhere is different. It becomes rumination. It produces condemnation rather than correction.
That distinction has helped me understand discernment more broadly.
Not every thought in my head deserves obedience simply because it feels powerful.
Scripture tells us to “take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ” in 2 Corinthians 10:5. In its immediate context, Paul is addressing arguments and ideas raised against the knowledge of God, but the principle has become important in how I examine my own thinking: my thoughts do not get to sit above Christ.
That includes thoughts I believe may be direction from God.
They need to be tested.
Hardship Does Not Automatically Mean I Misheard God
This became especially difficult after the move.
There absolutely were moments when I questioned whether I had understood God's direction correctly. But underneath those questions remained a strong conviction that I had obeyed what I believed God had asked me to do.
The problem was that I had unconsciously connected obedience with outcome.
If I obey God, shouldn’t things work out?
But obedience does not insulate us from hardship.
I took a tremendous financial risk to make the move. I incurred debt. I stretched my resources. I took what I believed was a leap of faith. The consequences of those decisions didn’t magically disappear because I believed I was being obedient.
And when things became difficult afterward, I had to confront something about faith that is much easier to talk about when life is going well.
Obedience is challenging when everything starts falling apart, because you still have to remain obedient.
That does not mean every difficult decision we make was commanded by God. It would be dangerous to use “God told me” as a way of avoiding responsibility for our own choices. Sometimes we can misunderstand. Sometimes our desires can influence what we think we are hearing. Sometimes we can simply be wrong.
That is exactly why discernment matters.
But I also don’t believe hardship by itself proves that we misunderstood God.
If difficulty were evidence of disobedience, an enormous amount of Scripture would become very difficult to explain. Faithfulness has never carried a promise that following God will produce the easiest available life.
What I Would Do Differently Now
Interestingly, if I believed God was calling me to do something difficult again tomorrow, I don’t think my response would be to question Him more.
I think I would try to become obedient sooner.
But I would also test what I believed I was hearing more deliberately.
I might take twenty-four hours. I would pray. I would take the direction I believed I had received and test it against Scripture and against the Spirit of God.
I would ask whether this direction was consistent with who God has revealed Himself to be.
I originally wanted to say I would determine whether it was in my best interest, but even that becomes complicated. Following God is not always immediately comfortable or obviously advantageous. Faith would hardly be faith if I already knew exactly how everything was going to turn out.
There eventually comes a point where discernment has to become trust.
I cannot spend forever demanding another sign before I obey.
Delayed obedience can become disobedience when I already know what I am being called to do. So there is a tension here that I am still learning to navigate: I should not recklessly act on every thought and call it God's voice, but I also should not use “discernment” as an excuse to postpone obedience indefinitely.
Test it. Pray. Search Scripture. Bring it before Christ.
Then, when I genuinely believe I know the direction I have been given, I have to be willing to move.
Obedience When I Don’t Feel God Near Me
Perhaps the hardest part of this experience has come afterward.
During the move, when I desperately needed God, I felt deeply connected to Him. Now, settled into ordinary life again, that connection does not feel nearly as strong.
I still pray. I still read Scripture. I still love Jesus.
But I do not consistently feel God's presence.
I believe continuing to show up anyway is itself an expression of faith.
Sometimes distance can become an opportunity for learning. It can become an opportunity to trust God without depending entirely upon the emotional experience of feeling close to Him. I am not claiming that every period of spiritual distance is God deliberately testing us. I don't know that.
What I do know is that my responsibility to remain faithful does not disappear because I don't feel what I once felt.
Jesus still walks with me.
My responsibility is to continue praying, continue seeking Scripture, continue giving thanks, and continue working on the things in my life that require work—including my marriage and myself.
And I don't always hit that mark.
If I am being completely honest, more often than I would like, I miss it.
I don't pray enough. I don't read Scripture enough. There are days when seeking God becomes another thing competing with everything else demanding my attention. Yet if my faith is supposed to be part of the fabric of my life, I cannot seek God only when His presence feels obvious.
That may be one of the biggest lessons this entire experience has taught me.
I still cannot give someone a foolproof formula for determining whether every impression comes from God. I don't think such a formula exists. We can test what we believe we are hearing against Scripture. We can pray. We can examine whether it reflects the character of Christ. We can become more disciplined about making our thoughts subject to Him.
And then sometimes we still have to take a step without knowing what the next ten steps will look like.
That is where faith enters the equation.
I made a massive move believing God was calling me to make it. Some beautiful things happened along the way. Some painful things happened afterward. I have questioned myself. I have questioned my discernment. I have struggled with feeling distant from God.
But hardship has not convinced me that obedience was a mistake.
Instead, I am learning that following God is not proven by how smoothly life goes after I say yes.
Sometimes the harder act of faith is continuing to say yes after it doesn’t.
Related Faith Apparel
The call to keep moving in faith even when the whole road is not visible is reflected in our Walk by Faith — 2 Corinthians 5:7 Christian Hoodie.
0 comments